Effects of immigration on the mentally III—Does it produce psychological distress?

Abstract

This report explores psychological distress among immigrants seeking help from psychiatric outpatient clinics as compared with control nonpatient immigrants. Our hypothesis is that nonpsychotic mentally ill immigrants will react to acculturation by psychological distress similarly to healthy individuals. Three questionnaires were used in this survey: Demographic Psychosocial Inventory, Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI), and Psychiatric Epidemiology Research Interview—Demoralization Scale (PERI-D). They were completed by patient and control groups consisting of recent adult immigrants to Israel from the former Soviet Union. The patient group included 158 subjects seeking psychiatric help from outpatient clinics. Among them, 51 met ICD-10 criteria for neurotic, stress-related, and somatoform disorders; 41 for schizophrenia; 32 for mood disorders; 18 for organic illnesses; and 16 for personality disorders. The control group consisted of 222 immigrants with no previous psychiatric history, matched by gender and age to the patient group. Although all distress symptoms were signficantly more severe in the patient group than in the control group, the BSI profile, showing a high level of depression, anxiety, interpersonal sensitivity, and obsessive-compulsive dimensions, was similar in both groups. The psychological distress level as measured by the PERT-D was 1.4 times higher in patients than in the control group. Within the patient group, the lowest distress level was found in patients suffering from organic disorders. No significant differences in the level of psychological distress were found among other diagnostic subgroups. The results suggest that mentally ill immigrants react to acculturation by a psychological distress syndrome similarly to nonpatient immigrants but more severely than nonpatient immigrants.