Effects of fertilizer management practices on yield-scaled ammonia emissions from croplands in China: A meta-analysis

Abstract

China is the world’s largest emitter of gaseous ammonia (NH3), a compound carrying severe human health and ecosystem risks. Fertilizer N application is a major source of this atmospheric NH3. Although many studies have measured NH3 emissions from croplands in China, the effect of fertilizer management on yield-scaled NH3 emissions (i.e., NH3 intensity defined as NH3 emissions per unit crop yield) is not so clear. Thus, we performed a meta-analysis to quantify the effect of fertilizer management on NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity in China’s croplands. Results showed that the increases in NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity over a control were greater at high N rates (averaging 305kgNha−1) than at low and moderate N rates (average of 130 and 206kgNha−1, respectively), while crop yields stayed flat over this range. Rice had greater increases in NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity in response to inorganic N addition than other crops. The emission factor for NH3 was also higher for rice than other crops, and increased with increasing proportions of basal N and soil organic carbon and total N content. Relative to surface application, deep placement of fertilizer N significantly decreased NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity. Increasing the number of split applications of fertilizer N significantly reduced NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity. Organic manure amendments substituting for all or part of inorganic fertilizer N significantly mitigated NH3 emissions and led to a reduction in NH3 intensity but without statistical significance. The use of slow release fertilizers (SR) and urease inhibitors (UI) significantly reduced NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity, whereas application of nitrification inhibitors actually increased both. Overall, this meta-analysis demonstrates that appropriate fertilizer management practices such as reducing inorganic N rates, deep placement and split applications of fertilizer N, and using SR and UI can all reduce NH3 emissions and NH3 intensity in China’s croplands.