Effects of different nitrogen fertilization systems on crop yield and nitrogen use efficiency – Results of a field experiment in southern Germany

Abstract

The effects of the German Fertilizer Application Ordinance (GFO) on crop yield, nitrogen use efficiency and economical performance are highly controversial in science and practice in Germany. This study presents the results of a multi-year field experiment conducted at an experimental farm in southern Germany, in which the effects of different fertilizer systems on crop yield, protein concentration and nitrogen balance were analyzed.At this study site, relatively low N mineralization from the soil N pool was detected. Wheat (triticum aestivum L.) and barley (hordeum vulgare L.) showed strong yield declines from annual to multi-annual unfertilized plots, for maize (zea mays L.), this yield decrease was not observed. The recommendations according to GFO meets the fertilizer requirement at the trial site well. A 20% reduction of fertilization compared to GFO resulted in a 5% yield reduction and a decrease in protein concentration of wheat and barley.According to the quadratic N response function, the GFO treatment was slightly below the economic optimum nitrogen rate (Nopt) for wheat, and close to Nopt for winter barley on average over the trial years. For maize, a relatively high yield variability has been observed in the trial period so far. Sensor-based fertilization resulted in very high yields with high N use efficiency (up to 85%). This fertilization system can help to reduce nitrogen input and minimize nitrogen surplus.For wheat and barley, N fertilization and N uptake were well balanced, for maize clearly negative N surpluses were calculated. Despite all the discussion and criticism of GFO, the results of the plot trial show that high yields with high N use efficiency can be achieved with fertilization according to GFO.