Effectiveness of traffic management in Salt Lake City, Utah

Abstract

Problem The effectiveness of speed humps, 14 ft (4.3 m) wide by 3.5 in (8.9 cm) high, and tables, 22 ft (6.7 m) wide, on 12 streets in Salt Lake City, Utah was investigated. Mean and 85th percentile spot speeds, speed limit compliance, motor-vehicle crashes, and resident opinions were considered. Method Spot speeds were collected at 18 “between-hump” locations. Motor-vehicle crash data were obtained for “before” and “after” periods of equal duration. A total of 436 residents were surveyed; 184 responded. Results The mean and 85th percentile speeds decreased at 14 and 15 locations, respectively. The average reduction in the 85th percentile speed (3.4 mph or 5.4 km/h) was significant in flat and rolling terrain, but not on uphill or downhill segments. The number of sites with 50% speed limit compliance increased from 4 to 12. The number of motor-vehicle crashes decreased from 10 to 9; the change was not significant, but injury crashes decreased from five to one. Regarding the residents, 30% were positive, 25% were negative, and 45% offered suggestions, some of which were conflicting. Discussion Further study is needed on speed hump spacing and speed tables in hilly terrain. Example results should be shared with residents to inform their decision-making. Summary At least 78% of the sites experienced a decrease in the mean or 85th percentile speed, or an increase in speed limit compliance. Impact on Industry These findings should be useful to agencies that are planning or implementing traffic calming projects, and to analysts.