Effectiveness of Source-Zone Remediation of DNAPL-Contaminated Subsurface Systems

Abstract

Concerted efforts to remediate subsurface systems contaminated with dense nonaqueous-phase liquids (DNAPLs) have met with limited success when measured by comparing solute concentrations to drinking water quality standards. One-dimensional and three-dimensional laboratory experiments and a field-scale experiment are used to investigate the effectiveness of source-zone remediation and to assess factors that contribute to the observed results. The three-dimensional laboratory experiment and the field-scale experiment used a surfactant flush followed by vapor extraction to reduce the DNAPL saturation, while vertical DNAPL mobilization was controlled using a brine barrier. DNAPL mobilization and recovery in the field-scale experiment was relatively ineffective due in part to the low saturation levels of the DNAPL. The results show essentially that complete removal of a DNAPL is required to reach typical cleanup standards and that details of the morphology and topology of a DNAPL distribution, in addition to the saturation, play an important role in determining the rate of mass transfer. The results are interpreted in terms of guidance for remediation approaches, realistic expectations for source-zone remediation, and elements needed for improved models of such systems.