Effect of viral membrane fusion activity on antibody induction by influenza H5N1 whole inactivated virus vaccine

Abstract

Whole inactivated virus (WIV) influenza vaccines are more immunogenic in unprimed individuals than split-virus or subunit vaccines. In mice, this superior immunogenicity has been linked to the recognition of the viral ssRNA by endosomal TLR7 receptors in immune cells, leading to IFNα production and Th1-type antibody responses. Recent data suggest that viral membrane fusion in target cell endosomes is necessary for TLR7-mediated IFNα induction. If so, virus inactivation procedures that compromise the fusion activity of WIV vaccines, like formaldehyde (FA) treatment, could potentially harm vaccine efficacy. Therefore, we measured the effect of fusion inactivation of H5N1 WIV on TLR7 activation in vitro, and on antibody isotype responses in vivo. Fusion inactivation of WIV reduced, but did not block, TLR7-dependent IFNα induction in murine dendritic cells in vitro. In vivo, fusion-inactive WIV was as potent as fusion-active WIV in inducing total H5N1-specific serum IgG and IgG2c subtype antibodies in unprimed mice. Both vaccines induced only small amounts of IgG1. However, FA treatment of WIV did reduce the capacity of the vaccine to induce hemagglutination-inhibiting (HI) antibodies. This possibly relates to modification of epitopes that are targets for HI antibodies rather than to loss of fusion activity. Antibody affinity maturation was not negatively affected by fusion inactivation. In conclusion, fusion activity of H5N1 WIV does not play a major role in Th1-type antibody induction. Yet, to preserve the full immunogenicity of WIV, or possibly also other inactivated influenza vaccines, harsh treatment with formaldehyde should be avoided.