Effect of the Addition of a Low Equivalent Stress Mechanism to the Analysis of Geomechanical Behavior of the SPR West Hackberry Site

Abstract

Sandia National Laboratories has long used the Munson - Dawson (M - D) model to predict the geomechanical behavior of salt caverns used to store oil at the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR). Salt creep causes storage caverns to deform inward, thus losing volume. This loss of volume affects the salt above and around the caverns, puts stresses and strains on borehole casings, and creates surface subsidence which affects surface infrastructure. Ther efore, accurate evaluation of salt creep behavior drives decisions about cavern operations. Parameters for the M - D model are typically fit against laboratory creep tests, but nearly all historic creep tests have been performed at equivalent stresses of 8 M Pa or higher. Creep rates at lower equivalent stresses are very slow, such that tests take months or years to run, and the tests are sensitive to small temperature perturbations (<0.1C). A recent collaboration between US and German researchers, recently characterized the creep behavior at low equivalent (deviatoric) stresses (<8 MPa) of salt from the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant. In addition, the M - D model was recently extended to include a low stress creep ?mechanism?. This paper details new simulation s of SPR caverns that use this extended M - D model, called the M - D Viscoplastic model. The results show that the inclusion of low stress creep significantly alters the prediction of steady - state cavern closure behavior and indicate that low stress creep is the dominant displacement mechanism at the dome scale. The implications for evaluating cavern and well integrity are demonstrated by investigating three phenomena: the extent of stress changes around the cavern; the predicted vertical strains applied to wellbore casings; and the evaluation of oscillating str ess changes around the cavern due to oil sale cycles and their potential effect on salt fatigue.