Effect of substrate depth on 18 non-succulent herbaceous perennials for extensive green roofs in a region with a dry spring

Abstract

Appropriate vegetation is critical for green roofs to perform their social and ecological functions. This study was conducted on a third-story rooftop to investigate the effect of substrate depth on the establishment of plants for potential use on unirrigated extensive green roofs in Beijing, China. Eighteen non-succulent herbaceous perennial species were tested on substrates of three different depths (10cm, 15cm and 20cm) from October 2012 to November 2013. Measurements included plant survival, growth index (GI), visual appearance, coverage and substrate moisture content. It was concluded that the major cause of plant mortality in unirrigated green roofs in Beijing was not summer water deficit, but the water deficit that occurs during Beijing's natural dry spring. Deeper substrate promoted higher survival during this water stressed period. Most species exhibited the greatest GI and visual rating at the depth of 20cm. Of the 18 species tested, three geophytes were the most drought-tolerant. Only Allium senescens was found to be suitable for use in unirrigated green roofs with substrates no deeper than 10cm. Iris ‘Music Box’ and Hemerocallis ‘Stella de Oro’ are also suitable for unirrigated green roofs if planted at substrate depths of at least 15cm and a depth of 20cm facilitated survival of the greatest number species. Supplemental irrigation is highly recommended for extensive green roofs with non-succulent herbaceous perennials in Beijing and other similar climate regions with the same temporal distribution of precipitation. Nepeta cataria and Saponaria ocymoides are also potential species for unirrigated extensive green roofs because of their capacity for self seeding.