Effect of Setting Time on Viscosity Stability of Xanthan Gum- and Starch-Based Thickened Beverages for Patients with Dysphagia: Comparison of IDDSI Syringe Flow Test and Line-Spread Test.

Abstract

Because the viscosity of thickened beverages prepared with thickeners gradually changes before consumption, achieving their desired viscosity is important for managing dysphagia. This study aimed to investigate the viscosity changes of thickened beverages (water, orange juice, and milk) prepared with xanthan gum (XG)- and starch-based commercial thickeners over time using the syringe flow test (SFT) and line-spread test (LST). The LST values of beverages stabilized more quickly (≤1.5 h) than the SFT values (2.0∼3.5 h) at level 2 (mildly thick), whereas the opposite finding was observed at level 3 (moderately thick). After stabilization in a water system, SFT and LST yielded similar results. However, the SFT values of orange juice and milk thickened with XG-based thickener exceeded the reference values at level 2 and gradually increased at level 3. These results may be attributed to particulates interrupting fluid flow from the small tip of the syringe and the high friction force caused by the contact between the thickened sample and the syringe surface. The results suggest that the LST method is more reliable than the SFT method in clearly distinguishing between levels 2 and 3 of thickened beverages and demonstrate that the viscosity measurements of thickened beverages over time after preparation were strongly influenced by the measurement tools used for predicting the thickness level.