Effect of molecular structure on membrane diffusion: Triphenylmethanes across Escherichia coli studied by second harmonic light scattering

Abstract

Understanding how the structure of molecules affects their permeability across cell membranes is crucial for many topics in biomedical research, including the development of drugs. In this work, we examine the transport rates of structurally similar triphenylmethane dyes, malachite green (MG) and brilliant green (BG), across the membranes of living Escherichia coli (E. coli) cells and biomimetic liposomes. Using the time-resolved second harmonic light scattering technique, we found that BG passively diffuses across the E. coli cytoplasmic membrane (CM) 3.8 times faster than MG. In addition, BG exhibits a diffusion rate 3.1 times higher than MG across the membranes of liposomes made from E. coli polar lipid extracts. Measurements on these two molecules, alongside previously studied crystal violet (CV), another triphenylmethane molecule, are compared against the set of propensity rules developed by Lipinski and co-workers for assessing the permeability of hydrophobic ion-like drug molecules through biomembranes. It indicates that BG’s increased diffusion rate is due to its higher lipophilicity, with a distribution coefficient 25 times greater than MG. In contrast, CV, despite having similar lipophilicity to MG, shows negligible permeation through the E. coli CM on the observation scale, attributed to its more hydrogen bonding sites and larger polar surface area. Importantly, cell viability tests revealed that BG’s antimicrobial efficacy is ∼2.4 times greater than that of MG, which aligns well with its enhanced diffusion into the E. coli cytosol. These findings offer valuable insights for drug design and development, especially for improving the permeability of poorly permeable drug molecules.