Effect of informational charts on patient understanding of nontherapeutic research procedures in phase I trials.

Abstract

e24193 Background: It is difficult for patients to distinguish non-therapeutic from therapeutic procedures in research. In phase I trials, day 1 pretreatment biological samples are used for research and care; posttreatment samples are for research purposes only. Preliminary data suggested patients did not understand this difference. Our study tested to see if a simple information chart would improve understanding of the nontherapeutic research procedure. Methods: A sequential two arm study was conducted. Controls (C) were asked whether samples taken at different times on day 1 of the trial were to be used for their care, for research only, or for both. The experimental (E) group provided patients with a study-specific information chart labeling the purpose of required samples and patients were then asked the same questions. Results: 100 patients (50 each C and E) were interviewed after consenting to a trial. Patients were mostly white (63%), male (53%), with an annual income > $60,000 (51%); 49% had a college degree. In both arms, understanding that pretreatment samples were for patient care and research was moderate (50% C; 62% E). Understanding that posttreatment samples were for research was significantly higher in the experimental arm (16% C; 44% E p = 0.002). Conclusions: Questions regarding the purpose of biological samples taken pre-administration of study drug were less susceptible to therapeutic misconception due to the “both” option being true. Since the provision of an informational chart significantly improved understanding of the purpose of the posttreatment sample, we suggest that providing such a chart may help alleviate this type of therapeutic misconception. [Table: see text]