Effect of force direction and tooth angulation during traction of palatally impacted canines: A finite element analysis

Abstract

Treatment of a palatally impacted canine (PIC) is associated with demanding anchorage control, increased treatment duration, and undesirable side effects. Accurate PIC localization and force application impact treatment success. The objective of this research was to determine the stresses on the PIC when subjected to initial force activation in various directions (buccal, vertical, and distal) and relative to impaction severity. Thirty PICs from 21 scans underwent finite element modeling. A prototype 3D model was reconstructed and segmented into its anatomic components. Each PIC was precisely positioned in the prototype model according to impaction position. Stresses in response to a (1.0N) force in the distal, vertical, and buccal directions were evaluated at different levels of the root (apical, middle, and cervical). Distal and buccal forces yielded higher stress (6.64 and 6.41kPa, respectively) than the vertical force (5.97kPa) on the total PIC root and the apical and cervical root levels, but not at midroot. Statistically significant differences between severity groups were found mostly at the apical level among all force directions, except between distal and buccal forces in the higher severity group. In this group, stress was greatest at the cervical level with the buccal force significantly different from the stresses generated by either the distal or the vertical force. Vertical forces generated the lowest stresses. Differentially distributed stresses over the root reflected an initial tipping movement. Greater cervical stresses from the buccal force indicate resistance to movement, suggesting treatment initiation with vertical and distal forces over buccal forces, particularly with severely inclined canines.