Effect of early transplanting upon growth and development of spruce and pine seedlings in paperpot containers

Abstract

Black spruce (Picea mariana [Mill.] B.S.P.) and jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) seedlings were transplanted into Japanese paperpots at five different stages of development between the occurrence of an erect hypocotyl and 14 days after initiation of primary needles. Transplanting difficulty increased between the first and last treatments, and transplanting generally became impracticable after the stage of primary-needle initiation. Transplanting had a relatively minor effect on the eventual size of 12-week-old pine and 16-week-old spruce seedlings, although the incidence of root deformities inside the container increased rapidly as transplanting was delayed beyond the erect-hypocotyl stage. These deformities persisted after seedlings were outplanted, but did not appear to have a negative effect on the subsequent growth of new roots into the planting medium. Despite the absence of major adverse effects, it is recommended that transplanting be avoided as a routine practice for supplementing stocking in trays of containerized seedlings because of possible biological risks, the difficulty of ensuring careful transplanting and high labor costs.