Effect existence of aging on stutter ratio evaluated via Bayesian inference

Abstract

The stochastic behavior of the stutter ratio (SR) in capillary electrophoresis-based DNA typing is currently described and predicted using statistical models in forensic genetics. Clarifying this behavior can help obtain more objective and robust evidence to the court in terms of mixture interpretation. This study aimed to investigate the effect existence of aging on SR via a Bayesian framework. Nail scrapings and clippings were collected from 68 healthy individuals with informed consent. Samples were classified by age-class: young group (0–16 years; n = 36) and older-adult group (>61 years; n = 32). Then, they were compared in terms of their SRs for each simple repeat locus included in GlobalFiler Kit. Bayesian modeling was performed with lognormal distribution model, which implemented multiple linear regression, allele and age-class as explanatory variables. For all simple repeat loci, the median of the posterior distribution of the age-class parameter was a positive value. For CSF1PO and D7S820, the 95% credible interval of the posterior distribution did not include 0. Our data suggested that aging slightly increases the SR. These findings might help elucidate the stochastic behavior of SR.