Economic and entropy production evaluation of extractive distillation and solvent-assisted pressure-swing distillation by multi-objective optimization

Abstract

Extractive distillation (ED) and solvent-assisted pressure-swing distillation (SA-PSD) are both special distillation processes that perform good at separating pressure-insensitive azeotropes. However, few reported studies have compared the performance of the two processes. In this paper, ED processes with N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP) and dimethlac-etamide (DMCA) as entrainer, SA-PSD process with isopropyl-alcohol (IPA) as solvent and SA-PSD process with partial heat integration (PHI-PSD) are proposed to achieve high purity separation of a mixture of cyclohexane/2-butanol system. The optimal operating conditions of the processes are obtained after optimizing with NSGA-II algorithm when total annual cost (TAC) and the entropy production of process are set as objectives. The optimal results show that the optimal PHI-PSD process has lower TAC by 28.7% and the lower entropy production by 39.5% than the optimal SA-PSD process while the ED process with NMP as entrainer has lower TAC by 50.9% and the lower entropy production by 56.1% than the optimal SA-PSD process. The optimal results show that the ED process with NMP as entrainer has the best economic and thermodynamic efficiency among the four proposed processes in this paper.