Ecological gradients in a marine cave revisited 26 years after

Abstract

Marine caves are unique and vulnerable habitats threatened by multiple global and local pressures. Changes in the sessile epibenthic community of the Grotta Azzurra of Capo Palinuro (Salerno, Italy) during the last 26 years have been evaluated using growth forms and trophic guilds as non-taxonomic descriptors, informative of the structure and the functioning of the cave ecosystem, respectively. Photographic samples were collected in 1992 and 2018 to investigate the stability of the ecosystem response to the three main environmental gradients occurring inside the cave: i) confinement, ii) depth, and iii) light. Benthic communities were well spatially distributed along the three gradients inside the cave according to both the morphology and the feeding strategy of organisms, although the zonation was less marked considering trophic guilds. Gradients persisted and zones remained distinct through time, notwithstanding significant changes in community composition. The trophic organization was preserved throughout the cave, but significant changes in the spatial organization of benthic assemblages were widely observed, mainly due to 3-dimensional growth forms replaced by 2-dimensional (i.e., encrusting) growth forms and by increased sedimentation, thus causing the structural homogenization of the cave community. The outermost and the deepest sectors of the cave experienced higher changes compared to the most confined, blind-ended, sector and to the shallowest depths, which resulted comparatively more stable. From a functional point of view, filter feeders always dominated the communities (even considering their shift from erect to encrusting morphologies) and the few observed changes were due to the reduction of photophilic autotrophs and active ciliate without lophophore and the increase of mixotrophic sponges. As local human pressures remained low through the period considered, the changes observed are likely to be mainly due to global warming, which caused increased sea surface water temperatures and repeated summer heat waves (reported in 1994, 2003, 2008, 2012, and 2015). Regular monitoring programs on marine caves should be promoted to create historical series of data precious to better understand magnitude and pattern of change in the long-term evolution, and to estimate the recovery time of such priority habitats.