Earth’s first snowball event: Evidence from the early Paleoproterozoic Huronian Supergroup

Abstract

Ever since it was first proposed that the Earth completely froze during glaciations ∼ 640 million years ago evidence supporting this hypothesis has been increasing, primarily from samples of carbonates directly overlying glacial diamictites, termed cap carbonates. However, this was not the first extensive glacial period that affected planet Earth: ∼1750 million years prior to Neoproterozoic glaciations the Earth went through its first major glacial episode, the early Paleoproterozoic Huronian glaciations. The second Huronian ice advance deposited the Bruce Formation, with its overlying cap carbonate, the Espanola Formation. This up to ∼ 300 m thick succession of limestone, siltstone, dolostone and sandstone overlies diamictite containing a dropstone-bearing layer with δ13Ccarb of −10‰. The 12C-enriched interval also has rare earth element (REE) patterns with negative Eu anomalies, radiogenic Sr isotopes, and negative εNd(0) in the carbonate. The first of these observations is probably due to highly reducing conditions in the sediment, and the possible thawing of methane-rich areas, releasing fluids that mixed with the overlying bottom waters; the last two reflect the diagenetic incorporation into the carbonate of radiogenic Sr, and derivation of REEs, including Nd, from abundant silty loess. This infers a stratified water mass with a relatively stagnant bottom layer during disintegration of an ice shelf. Above this REE patterns through the basal Espanola become increasingly more light depleted upwards, C becomes heavier, Sr is less radiogenic, εNd(0) is near 0 and one area has up to ∼ 1300 ppm Ba incorporated into the carbonate, indicating breakdown of water-mass stratification. Vertically over ∼ 200 m δ13Ccarb increases from −4.5 to −2.5‰ as the environment shallowed incorporating gradually increasing amounts of seawater into the freshwater plume, which initially extended to depths below wave base. Strata deposited in the upper Espanola near the strandline contain layers of Fe-Mn-rich dolomite with positive Eu anomalies reflecting Paleoproterozioc seawater composition dominating even the nearshore by this time. These observations are similar to those from Neoproterozoic cap carbonates, and provide new evidence for the possibly snowball Earth-like nature of the ∼ 2.4 Ga Bruce glaciation.