Early-stage impacts of sika deer on structure and function of the soil microbial food webs in a temperate forest: A large-scale experiment

Abstract

Modification of forest vegetation caused by an overabundance of mammalian herbivores has been reported in temperate and subarctic regions all over the world. However, the indirect effects of these herbivores on the structure and functions of soil decomposer systems are not fully understood, especially in temperate forests. We investigated the early effects of sika deer invasion on soil decomposer systems in a Japanese temperate forest using two large-scale experimental enclosures with low and high densities of deer (LD: 25ha, 4deerkm−2; HD: 6.25ha, 16deerkm−2) including control plots without deer (WD). Three years after deer introduction the understory cover of dwarf bamboo (Sasa nipponica) declined due to deer browsing in both enclosures. At the same time, measurements were made of the soil microbial community, soil nematode community, soil nitrogen (N) mineralization rate, and carbon (C) and N content in dwarf bamboo leaves. In LD, soil microbial biomass was lower from WD, probably due to the decrease of fresh aboveground litter from dwarf bamboo. Surprisingly, there were no cascading effects on total abundance of soil nematodes and soil total N mineralization potential which were unaffected by deer in the LD treatment, while soil NH4+-N content was lower and soil nematode community structure was different (abundance of 4 families was higher and that of 3 families was lower, but the functional structure was not different) from WD. Specifically, the responses to deer introduction varied between microbes and nematodes, and the change of balance in the microbial food webs may have altered N mineralization processes. In contrast, in the HD treatment, all the variables measured were not significantly different from those of WD treatment. Intensive browsing by deer may have cancelled out the effects of the decrease in aboveground litter input on the soil decomposer systems through other pathways, such as a transitory increase in belowground litter input caused by induced changes in allocation patterns of bamboo. No changes in total N mineralization potential, leaf N, and composition of understory vegetation in both enclosures indicated that deer introduction did not facilitate nor retard N cycling regardless of deer density. This study showed that sika deer browsing can affect soil decomposer systems at an early stage of invasion even at low density, which contrasts with previous studies on the subject. Linking our findings of early-stage effects of deer on soil decomposer systems to longer-term dynamics of understory vegetation and tree regeneration will be needed to evaluate the adequacy of deer management practices with respect to the sustainability of soil nutrient supplies.