Early prostate-specific antigen failure following radical perineal versus retropubic prostatectomy: the importance of seminal vesicle excision

Abstract

Objectives. Because of renewed interest in the radical perineal prostatectomy, we chose to evaluate factors influencing differences in biochemical failure as measured by prostate-specific antigen (PSA) between radical perineal and the radical retropubic prostatectomies. Methods. We undertook a retrospective review of 87 men with clinically localized prostate cancer who underwent radical retropubic (64%) or radical perineal (36%) prostatectomy, noting age, race, preoperative PSA, Gleason score, clinical stage, capsular penetration, surgical approach, and completeness of seminal vesicle (SV) excision. The two groups were comparable with respect to tumor factors such as preoperative PSA, Gleason score, clinical stage, and capsular penetration. Time to postoperative PSA failure (0.2 ng/mL or greater) was evaluated with univariate and multivariate analysis of multiple contributing factors. Results. Twenty-eight percent of patients had a PSA level rising to 0.2 ng/mL or greater in the follow-up period. Patients who underwent perineal prostatectomy had a higher PSA failure rate (45%) than those treated by the retropubic approach (18%) and patients with incomplete SV excision had a higher failure rate (69%) than patients with bilateral SV excision (20%). When time to PSA failure was examined by multivariate analysis, completeness of SV excision, clinical stage, and Gleason score had a statistically significant impact on this outcome. In perineal prostatectomy patients, bilateral SV excision had a significantly longer time to PSA failure than in patients with incomplete excision. There was no significant difference in time to PSA failure between patients who underwent radical retropubic prostatectomy and the patients who underwent perineal prostatectomy with bilateral SV excision. Conclusions. Incomplete excision of SVs during a radical perineal prostatectomy contributes to an earlier postoperative biochemical recurrence as measured by a rising PSA, and may explain the higher disease recurrence rate for radical perineal prostatectomies as opposed to radical retropubic prostatectomies in this study.