Early gestational mesencephalon grafts, but not later gestational mesencephalon, cerebellum or sham grafts, increase dopamine in caudate nucleus of MPTP-treated monkeys.

Abstract

The mechanism of the behavioral improvement observed in parkinsonian primates that receive intrastriatal transplants of fetal dopamine neurons has not been firmly established. Dopamine production by grafted neurons may be the basis of the behavioral recovery. Alternatively, stimulation of the host dopamine system by the transplant procedure itself may be central to the outcome. The present study examined whether dopamine concentration was raised in the caudate nucleus of the 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP)-treated primate following grafting, and if so, whether the elevation was dependent on either (i) the introduction of the implantation cannula (sham), (ii) the brain region that was grafted, or (iii) the gestational age of fetal tissue that was grafted. Transplantation of early gestational age fetal ventral mesencephalon (embryonic days 40-50) was associated with significant elevation of caudate nucleus dopamine concentration to a mean of approximately 20% of control values in the vicinity (within 2 mm) of the graft, compared with more distant sites in the caudate nucleus. With early gestational age fetal ventral mesencephalon, the ratio of homovanillic acid/dopamine concentration near the graft site was normalized compared to the elevated value found in the caudate nucleus distant from the graft site. Grafts of later stage fetal ventral mesencephalon, or fetal cerebellum, or sham implantation did not increase dopamine concentration or lower homovanillic acid/dopamine ratio near the graft site. Biochemical and histochemical evidence suggests that host dopamine neurons terminating in the nucleus accumbens are not the source of the changes. Numerous tyrosine hydroxylase-positive neurons at the graft site were only observed in the MPTP-treated monkeys that received grafts of early gestational age fetal ventral mesencephalon. These data lend strong support to the hypothesis that dopamine derived from grafted dopamine neurons is the major basis for behavioral recovery observed following intrastriatal transplantation in our MPTP-treated monkeys.