Dynamic and quantitative characterization of antagonism within disinfectant mixtures by a modified area-concentration ratio method

Abstract

The coexistence of various typical disinfectant pollutants has the potential to produce toxicity interaction towards organisms in the environment. A suitable model is necessary to evaluate the interaction quantitatively. Hence, the area-concentration ratio (ACR) method was modified (MACR) by combing confidence intervals to dynamically and quantitatively evaluate the toxicity interactions within disinfectant mixture pollutants. Disinfectant mixtures were designed by the direct equipartition design ray method using three guanidine disinfectants, chlorhexidine diacetate (CD), chlorhexidine (CHL), and polyhexamethylene biguanidine (POL) and one chlorine-containing disinfectant calcium hypochlorite (CAL). The toxicities of the four disinfectants and their mixtures towards Vibrio qinghaiensis sp.-Q67 (Q67) were determined by the time-dependent toxicity microplate analysis method. And the toxicity mechanism was analyzed by determining the effects of four disinfectants and their binary mixtures on the structure of cell, DNA and proteins (Pro) for Q67. The results show that the toxicities of CD and CHL to Q67vary little with time, but POL and CAL show the obvious time-dependent toxicity. The toxicities of CD, CHL and POL to Q67 are significantly stronger than that of CAL at the same exposure time. The toxicities of three binary mixture systems don’t have significant difference in different exposure time. MACR can dynamically, quantitatively and accurately characterize toxicity interactions compared with ACR. According to MACR, the antagonism intensity dynamically changes with the prolongation of exposure time for binary mixture rays of three guanidine disinfectants and CAL, and linearly correlates with the components’ concentration ratios. Four disinfectants all can destroy cell membrane and cause desaturation DNA of test organism, and CAL even can destroy the structure of DNA and protein. The probably reason for the antagonism within binary mixtures is the reaction between guanidine group and ClO-, which is called chemical antaogism.