Abstract

In this paper we describe the genesis of a doomsday scenario and discuss potential causes and motivations for a breakup of the euro area. For this purpose, we differentiate between the departure of weak and strong countries, and examine the impact of the reintroduction of a national currency on domestic debt, the domestic banking sector, EU membership and the freedom of trade. We also briefly analyze the social and political costs of the accompanying social disorder.

Highlights

  • In this paper we describe the genesis of a doomsday scenario and discuss potential causes and motivations for a breakup of the euro area

  • Using the breakdowns of Argentina or Uruguay a decade ago as a guide rather than the relatively mild European Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) I disruptions [5], it is reasonable to assume that the external value of the currency of a weak country seceding from the euro zone might fall by up to 60 percent vis-à-vis the “rump euro” bloc

  • UBS [1], for instance, argues convincingly that if a new national currency were to depreciate by 60 percent against the euro, it seems highly plausible that the euro area in turn would impose a 60 percent tariff against the exports of the departing country

Read more

Summary

Preliminaries

It is time to admit that under the prevailing structure and membership, the euro area does not work successfully. Either the current institutional setting or the composition of its membership will have to undergo changes This has led many observers to describe potential doomsday scenarios, including the conclusion by [1] that “the euro should not exist (like this).”. Countries belonging to the Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) cannot be expelled from the common currency, but sovereign nations could secede. This breakup option is associated with substantial risk, is extraordinarily costly and is assessed as being a very improbable event. If the lack of growth continues, the option of seceding from the monetary union could become a dominant end-game strategy for some current euro area members. Rather than systematically assessing the most widely discussed options for keeping the euro together, this paper investigates likely channels for the transmission of economic impacts, as well as the overall consequences of breaking up the euro—the variants of doomsday for the euro area [1]

The Problem with the Euro and the Anti-Euro Bet
The Disaster Scenario–Characterizing Breakup and Its Consequences
Breakup and Doomsday–the Scenarios
The Basic Mechanics of Doomsday with a Weak Country Leaving
Default on Domestic Debt and Breakdown of the Domestic Banking Sector
EU Membership at Stake
Protectionism Back again
Quantifying Economic Costs–Referencing the UBS and HSBC Studies
The Basic Mechanics of Doomsday Given a Strong Country Departure
Default on Domestic Debt and Breakdown of the Domestic Banking System
EU Membership at Stake as Well
Protectionism Mark II
Findings
Quantifying Economic Costs-Referencing the UBS and HSBC Studies
Conclusions
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.