Does treatment modality have an impact on anemia in patients with chronic renal failure? Effect of low- and high-flux biocompatible dialysis.

Abstract

Renal anemia significantly affects the morbidity and mortality of dialysis patients. The aim of the present study was to establish whether the severity of anemia and success of its treatment differs when using high-flux (HF) or low-flux (LF) hemodialysis. Twenty-five patients on long-term hemodialysis with a mean hematocrit (Hct) of 33%, S alb of 36 g/L, and Kt/V urea of 1.5 were divided into Groups X (n = 13) and Y (n = 12) in a prospective randomized crossover study. Group X was initially treated with LF hemodialysis to be followed by HF hemodialysis for 8 weeks each time. Group Y started with 8 week HF hemodialysis and continued, after crossover, with 8 weeks of LF hemodialysis. HF and LF hemodialysis were performed with polysulfone dialyzers F 7HPS and F60S (Fresenius Medical Care, Bad Homburg, Germany). Hct values, examined at 2 week intervals, did not differ significantly between Groups X and Y during 16 weeks of the study at any measuring interval. In another analysis, all results of HF hemodialysis (first 8 weeks of Y + second 8 weeks of X) were pooled as were all data of LF hemodialysis (first 8 weeks of X + second 8 weeks of Y). No significant relationships were noted between duration of treatment with HF hemodialysis and Hct (n = 72, rS = 0.11, p = 0.36) and between duration of LF hemodialysis and Hct (n = 74, rS = 0.02, p = 0.87) in the newly formed groups. The Hct measured during HF hemodialysis and LF hemodialysis did not differ significantly. Analysis of variance did not reveal a relationship between Hct and the HF or LF membrane. As HF and LF hemodialysis differed significantly in Kt/V urea, the variables were adjusted to identical Kt/V urea using analysis of covariance. No relationship between Hct and dialysis membrane permeability was demonstrated even in this case. Use of biocompatible LF and HF membranes in standard hemodialysis modes under conditions of adequate dose of dialysis and the time period studied did not result in different effects on anemia.