Does a pair of methane molecules aggregate in water?

Abstract

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of methane-water mixtures were performed using ab initio force fields for the CH4-H2O, H2O-H2O, and CH4-CH4 interactions. Both methane and water molecules were polarizable. From these calculations, the potential of mean force (PMF) between two methane molecules was extracted. Our results are compared with PMFs from a density-functional-theory (DFT) based Born-Oppenheimer type MD (BOMD) simulation, from a Monte Carlo (MC) simulation with ab initio-based force fields, and from MD simulations with empirical force fields. Our PMF is qualitatively similar to that obtained from the simulations with empirical force fields but differs significantly from those resulting from the DFT-BOMD and MC simulations. The depth of the PMF global minimum obtained in the present work is in a much better agreement with the experimental estimate than the result of the DFT-BOMD simulation, possibly due to the inability of DFT to describe the dispersion interactions and the lack of extensive sampling in the BOMD simulations. Our work indicates that, for a pair of methane molecules, there are configurations where the solvent increases the attraction between the solutes, but there are also conformations in which the solvent causes a weak net repulsion. On average, the methane molecules are more likely to be in the configuration where they are separated by a water molecule than in the one in which they are in contact even though the minimum of the PMF at the latter configuration is deeper than that at the former. Finally, we found that the water structure around methane solutes does not show a greater tetrahedral ordering than in neat bulk water.