Doctors’ voices generate support for abortion care: Results from a nationally representative survey

Abstract

ObjectiveWe tested abortion messaging to develop evidence-based communication recommendations for doctors who provide abortion care. Study DesignWe conducted an on-line survey in a nationally representative sample of 1,215 people, using NORC’s Amerispeak® Panel. We surveyed participants before and after viewing two brief videos featuring doctors who provide abortion care speaking about their work. Doctors’ comments were grounded in strategic communications and applied psychology research and emphasized caregiving roles, avoided political-sounding punditry, and acknowledged abortion’s complexities. We assessed participants’ characterizations of doctors who provide abortion care, how these characterizations impact support for abortion restrictions and overall views on abortion legality. We analyzed pre-post data using descriptive statistics, t-tests and multivariable regression. ResultsPost-messaging more participants endorsed positive descriptors of doctors who provide abortion care (p<0.001,t=8.99); fewer endorsed negative descriptors (p<0.001,t=10.32). Increased post-messaging endorsement of positive descriptors predicted declines in support for abortion restrictions (AOR = 1.69,p<0.01); decreased endorsement of negative descriptors did not. After messaging, 37% of respondents said their views of doctors who provide abortion care made them less likely to support abortion restrictions, compared to 14% before (p<0.001,t=-6.9). After messaging there was more overall support for legal, accessible abortion and less for abortion being mostly illegal (46%→48% and 24%→22%,p<0.001;t=-4.11). ConclusionsWhen doctors who provide abortion care use messaging recommendations that include speaking about abortion’s complexities and avoiding political-sounding punditry, they generate more support for legal abortion and less for restrictions. ImplicationsThe voices of doctors who provide abortion care shape abortion public opinion. When doctors speak from caregiving perspectives, avoid punditry, and acknowledge abortion’s complexities they generate more support for legal abortion and less for restrictions. However, audiences may not be aware a priori that ideas of doctors shape their views.