Do patients profit from 5-aminolevulinic acid-induced fluorescence diagnosis in transurethral resection of bladder carcinoma?

Abstract

Objectives To evaluate in a prospective study the influence of fluorescence diagnosis (FD) controlled transurethral resection of bladder tumors on therapeutic consequences. The aim was to determine in how many patients FD led to a change in treatment strategy compared with conventional white light (WL) cystoscopy. Methods A total of 279 patients with suspected bladder tumors underwent transurethral resection using FD in addition to WL cystoscopy. The number of additional tumor-positive patients, staging change, number of multilocular tumors exclusively detected by FD, and resulting therapeutic consequences compared with the results after WL cystoscopy were investigated. In addition a biopsy-based evaluation was performed. Results Tumor or dysplasia II° (moderate dysplasia) was detected in 177 patients. In 168 patients, tumor was detected by WL cystoscopy, and in 9 (5.1%) of the patients, tumor was completely overlooked by WL cystoscopy and diagnosed exclusively by FD (n = 3 TaG1-G2, n = 2 carcinoma in situ, n = 1 greater than T1, and n = 3 dysplasia II°). Multilocular tumor involvement was detected in 10 cases using FD, and a change in the stage by detection of coexisting dysplasia II° and carcinoma in situ occurred in 8 patients. In 27 patients (15.3%), additional information was obtained by exclusive detection of tumors by FD. This resulted in a change in the treatment strategy for 16 patients (9%). Conclusions FD leads to an improvement in the diagnosis of bladder carcinoma. It allows the early selection of the best treatment option and thus has a potentially positive effect on the prognosis of the affected patients.