DNR patterns in cancer patients (pts) 16 years after the Patient Self Determination Act (PSDA)

Abstract

6582 Background: In 1991, the PSDA required institutions receiving federal funding to inform pts about the right to refuse life prolonging treatments such as CPR. Studies conducted around 1991 suggest that most DNR orders are written by oncologists less than 3 days prior to death in hospitalized pts, raising ethical concerns. 16 years later, are oncology clinicians writing DNR orders earlier in cancer pts’ hospital course compared to non-cancer pts? Methods: We conducted a chart review of 284 of the 296 total adult deaths during 2005 at Indiana University Hospital. Demographic, diagnostic, and attending service info was collected from hospital billing records. Pts’ DNR status, timing of DNR orders, and presence of a written advanced directive (AD) were assessed through chart review. Results: 76 of 284 (26.8%) patients had cancer diagnoses. Of these, 59 had documented DNR orders. There was no difference in presence or absence of DNR orders at the time of death for cancer vs. non-cancer pts (77.6 vs 72.7%, p=0.35). Mean time from writing of the DNR order to death was 3.51 ± 4.61 days for cancer pts compared to 3.26 ±3.81 days for non-cancer pts (p=0.40), however, the majority of DNR orders written by oncologists were written less than 2 days prior to death. We calculated a ratio of the time between DNR order writing and death to the overall length of stay for cancer and non-cancer pts, excluding pts with very short lengths of stay ( = 5 days). In univariate analyses, this ratio trended toward statistical significance (p=0.08). In multivariate analyses, cancer pts had a higher ratio of the time between DNR order and death to LOS (0.30 vs 0.21, p=0.05). Existence of an AD had no significant impact on this ratio. Surgical specialists wrote DNR orders less frequently (64.2 vs 77.3%, p=0.02) and later than non-surgical specialists (mean 21 vs 10 days from admission, p=0.0008). Conclusions: In this study, DNR ordering patterns among hospitalized cancer and non-cancer pts have changed little since the PSDA. Although cancer pts on average had DNR orders written relatively earlier in their terminal hospital stay than non-cancer pts, the timing varied little from pts in prior studies. Although the majority of hospitalized pts in this sample died with DNR orders, these orders were written very late in their hospital stay. No significant financial relationships to disclose.