Diversity, speciation, endemism and extinction in Devonian reef and level-bottom communities, eastern North America

Abstract

Lower Devonian late Emsian (Bois Blanc and Clear Creek Limestones; Schoharie Formation) level-bottom communities in New York, Michigan and Illinois were moderately cosmopolitan and diverse and dominated by brachiopods and solitary rugose corals. Subsequently (Early Eifelian?), there was an important episode of cratonal patch reef building in New York (Edgecliff Member, Onondaga Limestone), southwestern Ontario (Formosa Reef Limestone, lower Detroit River Group), and the Hudson Bay Lowland (Kwataboahegan Formation) by highly diverse endemic communities. The Edgecliff reefs were built by corals whereas the Formosa and Kwataboahegan reefs were built primarily by stromatoporoids. The strong correlation between high diversity and high endemism during the reef-building episode suggests that these communities contained numberous, small species populations belonging to several major taxa — an example of rapid speciation by geographic isolation and genetic drift.