Disturbance and contrasting patterns of population structure in the brachiopod Terebratulina septentrionalis (Couthouy) from two subtidal habitats

Abstract

The population structures of Terebratulina septentrionalis (Couthouy) from exposed upper rock surface and semi-cryptic rock wall habitats at 33 m depth in the Gulf of Maine differ. Over a 3-yr period, population densities were consistently higher in rock wall habitats. Although both populations were dominated by juveniles (1–4 mm shell length), size-frequency distributions constructed from upper rock surface and rock wall populations were significantly different, as a result of a greater frequency of large brachiopods (> 20 mm shell length) in rock wall populations. Prominent modes occurred at 14–15 mm shell length in upper surface populations and at 19–20 mm length in rock wall populations. Recruitment was higher in rock wall habitats where ambient light intensities were significantly lower than on upper rock surfaces. Differences in recruitment are either the result of larval selection for shaded rock walls or differential juvenile mortality between habitats. The larvae of Terebratulina settle on a diverse array of substrata. These include bedrock, sandy polychaete tubes and algae in upper surface habitats and bedrock, calcareous polychaete tubes, and ascidians in rock wall habitats. Individuals attached to polychaete tubes and algae in upper surface habitats do not attain large body size (> 13 mm shell length). It is suggested that these differences in population structure reflect the greater intensity of disturbance in upper surface habitats. For example, the cod, Gadus morhua (Linnaeus), ingests brachiopods attached to algae and polychaete tubes in this habitat. Gastropod predation affects brachiopods in upper surface habitats but not in rock wall habitats. Predation by gastropods and asteroids is not size-specific. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that predation contributed to the decline in the abundance and diversity of articulate brachiopods since the Mesozoic, and suggest that the restriction of recent populations to semi-cryptic rock wall and crevice habitats is, in part, controlled by disturbance.