Abstract

This study systematically reviews 200 articles published over the past three decades to reveal how appropriability and appropriation have been explained and how those perspectives resonate with developments in the innovation environment. Our results show that despite the extensive stream of literature, little effort has been made to systematically advance theory on appropriability and appropriation. Based on and extending prior literature, we propose a conceptual framing that distinguishes appropriability and appropriation, and that explains how innovating organizations build their readiness to benefit from innovation and how they realize that potential. We outline appropriability as the potential to benefit from an innovation, which accrues through instruments of appropriability: isolating appropriability mechanisms and complementary assets; and appropriation as the realization of that potential, which manifests in private and social benefits when the instruments are employed in processes for exclusion, leverage, or disclosure. We highlight the strategic importance of aligning these elements and appropriability conditions in realizing appropriation outcomes. The paper closes with a discussion on the framework's applications and relevant future research avenues.

Highlights

  • The concepts of appropriability and innovation have been inter­ twined since the publication of the work of Schumpeter (1950)

  • Based on and extending prior literature, we propose a conceptual framing that distinguishes appropriability and appropriation, and that ex­ plains how innovating organizations build their readiness to benefit from innovation and how they realize that potential

  • We outline appropriability as the potential to benefit from an innovation, which accrues through in­ struments of appropriability: isolating appropriability mechanisms and complementary assets; and appropriation as the realization of that potential, which manifests in private and social benefits when the instruments are employed in processes for exclusion, leverage, or disclosure

Read more

Summary

Introduction

The concepts of appropriability and innovation have been inter­ twined since the publication of the work of Schumpeter (1950). The value cre­ ation logics have progressed to new frontiers, and trends like digitali­ zation, openness, and collaboration have shifted the bases of value capture (Appleyard and Chesbrough, 2017; Colm et al, 2020; Felin and Zenger, 2014; Koutroumpis et al, 2020; Manzini et al, 2017; Tekic and Willoughby, 2020; Zobel et al, 2017) These developments challenge research regarding how contemporary appropriability-related phenomena are understood and communi­ cated. The subsequent discussion builds on these findings, introduces the suggested framing, and demonstrates its applicability across different settings and as a basis for future research

Innovation appropriability: conceptual background and the need for an update
Method: systematic literature review
Purpose and research questions
Identification of search string and databases
Search process and study selection
Data extraction and synthesis
Varying views on appropriability and related challenges
Appropriability understood as protection?
Focus on the selection of appropriability mechanisms
Focus on intellectual property rights
Uncertainty about boundaries
Conceptual ambiguity: capturing multiple dimensions with one concept?
Definitions and elements of appropriability
Building appropriability potential
Proposing a renewed definition of appropriability
Realizing appropriation
Appropriation outcomes: realizing private and social returns
Proposing a revised definition of appropriation
Appropriability conditions: contextual and situational factors
Proposing a refined definition of appropriability conditions
Reframing appropriability and appropriation
Aligning the elements
Proposing a refined definition of appropriation strategy
Findings
10. Concluding remarks
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.