Disentangling conflicting molecular phylogenetic signals in nuclear and plastid DNA of the western Eurasian-Mediterranean grass genus Cynosurus and its relatives (Poaceae subtribes Cynosurinae and Parapholiinae)

Abstract

The western Eurasian-Mediterranean grass genus Cynosurus, comprising about 11 species, is morphologically well delimited by the regular occurrence of conspicuous sterile spikelets distal to the fertile ones on the outer, abaxial side of the inflorescences. However, our molecular phylogenetic study using nuclear ribosomal DNA (ITS, ETS) and plastid DNA sequences (trnL–F, matK) has shown that the genus is not monophyletic in its current delimitation, but consists of three distinct lineages. These lineages were found to be closely related to a group of 6–7 genera taxonomically assigned to the subtribe Parapholiinae. These Parapholiinae genera were consistently monophyletic in our analyses, but the suggested relationships to the three lineages of Cynosurus varied depending on the particular DNA region examined. This was the case for both plastid and nuclear DNA, with cytonuclear discordance and ‘chloroplast capture’ indicating earlier hybridization. Interestingly, hybridization also proved to be the most likely explanation even with regard to the 18S–26S cistrons of the nuclear ribosomal DNA, where an exceptional evolutionary divergence between ITS and ETS was found. The results highlight and illustrate the important role of hybridization in the evolution of grasses. In terms of taxonomy, our findings argue against maintaining a polyphyletic genus Cynosurus s.l. but instead argue for dividing it into three monophyletic genera: Cynosurus s.s., Falona, which is reestablished here, and Ciliochloa, which is described as a new genus. In addition, it is proposed that the two subtribes Cynosurinae and Parapholiinae be combined into a single subtribe Cynosurinae, which is also monophyletic. The possible genetic background of the formation of sterile spikelets and the occasional occurrence of inflorescences with consistently fertile spikelets are discussed. New combinations are Ciliochloa effusa, C. effusa var. obliquata, C. effusa var. fertilis, C. elegans, C. gracilis, C. turcomanica and Falona colorata.