Disentangle the drivers of soil organic carbon mineralization and their temperature sensitivity in both topsoil and subsoil: Implication of thermal stability and chemical composition

Abstract

Information about the temperature dependence of soil organic carbon (SOC) mineralization is important to predict the possible carbon (C) release from the terrestrial ecosystem facing global warming. However, the way in which SOC quality and mineral protection of SOC affects mineralization rates and their response to increasing temperature remains poorly understood. Here, we focused on investigating thermal stability and chemical composition of soils which differed greatly with the type and extent of organo-mineral associations, and revealing their implications for SOC mineralization. Chemical composition and thermal stability of SOC were analyzed with 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (13C NMR) and simultaneous thermogravimeteric analysis and differential scanning calorimetry (TG-DSC), respectively. Soil mineralization and its temperature sensitivity (Q10) were assessed by incubating soils at 15 and 25 °C for 90 days.Our results showed that SOC of subsoil was more biologically stable, but exhibited higher temperature sensitivity than those of topsoil. Significant differences in chemical composition and thermal stability of SOC were detected across soils developed from four parent materials but not between two soil layers, and indicators obtained from the two techniques showed apparent associations with depth-specific SOC mineralization rates. Increase in SOC mineralization rates at two incubation temperatures and two soil layers were observed when the soils were characterized by higher percentage of labile SOC fractions (i.e., O-alkyl C and organic carbon oxidized during exothermic reactions). The Q10 values of topsoil were positively and mostly related to the percentage of Alkyl C. In addition to notable relationships with chemical composition, the Q10 values of subsoil were positively correlated with Exo1/Exo2 ratios and Energy density values, and negatively correlated with TG-50. It was interesting to note that thermal stability was possibly as a function of soil texture and total oxides. Results from VPA analysis further revealed that SOC mineralization rates at two soil layers and Q10 of topsoil were mainly driven by SOC quality, while it was related to both SOC quality and chemical protection for subsoil, implying that factors controlling the temperature sensitivity of SOC mineralization were depth-specific. Altogether, substrate accessibility as a function of chemical composition and chemical protection would play vital role in determining the feedbacks of the subsoil SOC pool to the future climate warming.