Discussion on the paper entitled “Estimating elasticity modulus and uniaxial compressive strength of sandstone using indentation test” by E. Mousavi, A. Cheshomi and M. Ashtari [Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 169 (2018) 157–166

Abstract

A discussion on the paper by Mousavi et al. (2018) is presented. The paper is focused on the estimation of elastic modulus (E) and uniaxial compressive strength (UCS) of sandstone using indentation test. The authors concluded that the thickness effect of samples on the indentation indices (critical transition force (CTF) and indentation modulus (IM)) was negligible. They proposed a dimensionless surface parameter (S) to eliminate the size effect on the E and UCS. On the basis of the test results and analysis method presented in the paper by Mousavi et al. (2018), three aspects of indentation test need to be clarified: the methods to prevent the movement of rock specimens, the results obtained from indentation test and the effect of specimen sizes on the CTF and IM. Meanwhile, the present discussion paper proposed some references for the methods to prevent the movement of rock specimens and the methods to eliminate the size effect in indentation test.