Discordance of microsatellite instability and mismatch repair immunochemistry occurs depending on the cancer type

Abstract

Microsatellite instability (MSI) and deficiency of mismatch repair (dMMR) are key markers for predicting the response of immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) and screening for Lynch syndrome (LS). This study examined the incidences of and factors associated with the concordance of MSI and MMR in human cancers. A total of 518 formalin-fixed cancer tissues were analyzed for MSI and MMR immunohistochemistry (IHC). MSI was analyzed by a PCR-based method using Promega markers. Concordance with MMR expression and factors associated with concordance were analyzed. In 2 colorectal cancer samples, MMR IHC failed due to inadequate staining conditions. In the remaining 516 cancers, a high level of MSI (MSI-H) was identified in 113 cases, and dMMR was identified in 112. The concordance of MSI and MMR IHC was 98.3%. Only 9 cases (4 pancreatobiliary, 3 colorectal, and 2 endometrial cancers) were discordant. Of the 113 MSI-H cases, 4 (3.5%) were proficient MMR (pMMR); of the 403 microsatellite stability (MSS) cases, 5 (1.2%) were dMMR. The independent factors associated with MSI-H/dMMR included meeting Amsterdam II criteria, assay purpose, and sampling method. Multivariate analysis revealed that cancer type (gastrointestinal cancers or others) was associated with concordance of MSI and MMR IHC. Three LS cases with pancreatic or endometrial cancer demonstrated MSS and dMMR, and one biliary cancer showed MSI-H and pMMR. Discordance between MSI and MMR IHC occasionally occurs in pancreaticobiliary and endometrial cancers. When suspected, both MSI and MMR IHC should be done to judge the ICI indication and screen for LS.