Discerning Race: Humoralism and Jonson’s Comic Poetics in Every Man Out of His Humour

Abstract

ABSTRACT This article shows how Jonson devises a racialized comedy form to navigate the increasingly complex social terrain of early modern London. Reading the avant-garde “comical satire” Every Man Out of His Humour through the lens of Galenic humoralism, I argue that Jonson leverages the physiological discourse within his work to reimagine comedy’s definitive purpose as the knowledge-production of social discernment — that is, a cultural system or logic of “reading” the humoral body as a social sign of one’s status and interiority. Pretenders of wit, tobacco-fiends, and perfumed courtiers — these humor-ridden figures are racialized through Jonson’s comic poetics as immutably inferior readers, inherently lacking in understanding that the rules of social discernment are always fluid, and open to others’ manipulation. And conversely, Jonson begins to explore within the play a conception of the ideal, discerning reader as defined by his white, and ultimately undiscernible, corporeality.