Direct EXAFS evidence for incorporation of As5+ in the tetrahedral site of natural andraditic garnet

Abstract

Exceptionally high-quality X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) spectra of the As K-edge measured on a garnet from the Central Oslo Rift (Jamtveit et al. 1993) are presented and interpreted. The best fit to the extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectrum indicates that arsenic occurs predominantly as As5+ in the tetrahedral Si4+ site. The first shell As-O bond lengths of 1.69 angstrom are identical to those observed for As5+-O in sodium arsenate and the edge position of 11872 eV is also characteristic of As5+. Determination of oxidized As within the structure places an important constraint on fluid chemistry, but perhaps even more importantly, EXAFS fitting of outer shells (As-Ca 3.07,3.75, 5.71, 6.11 angstrom; As-Fe/Al 3.47, 5.35 angstrom; As-Si 3.88, 5.60, 5.91 angstrom) in this high-quality data set gives unequivocal evidence that AsO4-3 substitutes for SiO4-4 in the garnet tetrahedral site. This is, to the best of our knowledge, the first Such XAS study yielding direct evidence, through outer shell fitting, for both the coordination environment and oxidation state of arsenic within (as opposed to sorbed onto) a silicate mineral.