Differential response of zircon U?Pb isotopic systematics to metamorphism across a lithologic boundary: an example from the Hope Valley Shear Zone, southeastern Massachusetts, USA

Abstract

A detailed morphological, chemical and isotopic study of zircons from a single outcrop of two mineralogically and chemically distinct units of the late Precambrian Ponaganset gneiss was undertaken to investigate the effects of mylonitization and metamorphism on U-Pb isotopic systematics. Late Paleozoic, amphibolite-grade (approx. 600°C) mylonitization of the Ponaganset gneiss at this locality is associated with movement along the Hope Valley Shear Zone. The response of zircon to metamorphism in each gneiss unit is distinct: zircons in gray augen gneiss are uncorroded and not overgrown, whereas zircons from fluorite-bearing pink granitic gneiss are variably corroded and over 50% bear opaque overgrowths. The zircon overgrowths are chemically distinct from the primary cores, and contain high conentrations of Hf, U, HREE, and Th. Mylonite derived from the gray gneiss contains only a small population of Hf-U-rich metamorphic zircon, but zircons in the pink gneiss-derived mylonite are dominated by the Hf-U-rich metamorphic component. In terms of their U-Pb isotopic systematics, overgrowth-free zircons from both units are markedly discordant (gray, 10–20%, pink, 35%), but overgrown zircons from the pink gneiss are up to 70% discordant. Zircons from the mylonites yield younger Pb−Pb and U−Pb ages than those of the protolith gneisses, and isotopic data from each gneiss + mylonite pair define a linear array on concordia plots. Upper intercept ages of the gray gneiss (621+/−27 Ma) and the pink gneiss (635+/−50 Ma) indicate that the crystallization of both units was coeval, and the lower intercept ages (gray, 270+/−92 Ma; pink, 285+/−26 Ma) fall within the range of other published age estimates for Alleghanian metamorphism in southeastern New England (e.g., Zartman et al. 1988). New growth of zircon suggests that Zr was mobile during metamorphism. The presence of fluorite in the pink gneiss, and a discontinuity in log \(\left( {{{f_{{\text{H}}_{\text{2}} {\text{O}}} } \mathord{\left/{\vphantom {{f_{{\text{H}}_{\text{2}} {\text{O}}} } {f_{{\text{HF}}} }}} \right.\kern-\nulldelimiterspace} {f_{{\text{HF}}} }}} \right)\)values obtained from biotite across the pink gneiss-gray gneiss contact indicates that dissolution and reprecipitation of zircon may be related to local variations in HF fugacity. Zircon dissolution/reprecipitation in the pink gneiss, and the lack of similar features in the contiguous gray gneiss, suggests that the degree of isotopic perturbation of zircon during metamorphism is related to bulk chemistry, fluid chemistry and/or the degree of fluid-rock interaction.