Differential response of males of a subarctic population of Bluethroat Luscinina svecica svecica to playbacks of their own and foreign subspecies

Abstract

Differences in vocalization between subspecies of songbirds may influence intraspecific interactions including mate choice and territorial behavior, and contribute to their further divergence by strengthening pre-mating reproductive isolation. We have recently shown that songs of two Bluethroat subspecies, Luscinia svecica svecia and L. s. cyanecula, differ in spectral characteristics and structure. Here, in a first experimental test of whether these differences are biologically relevant, we compared responses of L. s. svecica males to both types of songs. Altogether 19 males from a subartic population in Abisko, Sweden, were exposed to playbacks of songs from the two subspecies, accompanied by display of a stuffed Bluethroat lacking subspecies-specific colour marks. These stimuli were presented in random order, separated by over 1 h. We evaluated two largely uncorrelated components of male responses: non-vocal territorial behavior, and singing activity. A significant difference in reaction to subspecies playbacks was observed in aggressive behavior: independently of the song order, males generally responded more strongly to playback of their own subspecies. In contrast, playback order rather than subspecies identity significantly influenced the singing activity, which usually increased in the second trial. A more detailed analysis nevertheless suggested that vocal responses of birds exposed first to playback of their own subspecies were stimulated in the subsequent trial but not vice versa. Our results show that Bluethroats clearly discriminate the two song types, indicating the potential for subspecies recognition. Further experimental work is needed to assess the general validity of these patterns.