Differences in mass-balance calculations resulting from alternative sampling and estimation techniques on Glacier No. 1, Tien Shan, China

Abstract

In May of 1990, three research groups from China, the Soviet Union and the United States visited Glacier No. 1 in the Ürümqi river basin, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region, northwestern China, in a cooperative effort to examine differences in mass-balance calculations resulting from sampling and estimation procedures. Three different snow-depth data sets were collected consisting of: (1) high-resolution depth transects covering the glacier, (2) depths taken from the permanent stake network, and (3) an intermediate data set constructed using the stake network and supplementary depth data from locations not covered by the stake network. The glacier was divided into ten elevation zones and the data were registered to a digital elevation model for analysis. Results show that the permanent stake network provides an accurate estimate of total mass balance if certain techniques are used for extrapolation to higher elevations, although estimates of mass balance for particular regions of the glacier are not accurate. Some regions were overestimated while others were underestimated, leading to a good overall estimate. The intermediate-resolution data set provided better within-zone estimates of mass balance, but was less accurate than the stake network for total mass balance.