Abstract

The same course in both an online and on-campus environment makes for an extended experimental comparison of learning outcomes, while controlling for two important variables: the instructor and the content of the course Students learn course content through four kinds of encounters—alone, one-to-one, one-to many, and many-to many.The online version of “Introduction to Shakespeare” course has consistently better learning outcomes than the on-campus version, as a result of the compelling nature of the one-to-one communication mode online and the textual nature of the many-to-many and one-to-many modes online. Text-based communication in the online class reinforces the skills pertinent to a literature class. Other crucial factors are online pedagogy and the self-selection. Ultimately, the differences between the online and F2F classrooms may be less crucial to learning outcomes than the degree to which the course design, regardless of technological environment, develops and supports students’ abilities to practice adult learning styles.

Highlights

  • From 2000-2002, I taught University of California Berkeley Extension Online English XB17, “Introduction to Shakespeare,” and simultaneously taught the on-campus equivalent, English 17, as a lecturer for U.C

  • Teaching the same class in both an online and oncampus environment makes for an extended experimental comparison of the learning outcomes of an online class directly against its on-campus equivalent, while controlling for two important variables: the instructor and the content of the course

  • I believe that the online version of my “Introduction to Shakespeare” course has consistently better learning outcomes than the on-campus version, as a result of the compelling nature of the one-to-one communication mode online and the textual nature of the many-to-many and one-to-many mode online

Read more

Summary

INTRODUCTION

From 2000-2002, I taught University of California Berkeley Extension Online English XB17, “Introduction to Shakespeare,” and simultaneously taught the on-campus equivalent, English 17, as a lecturer for U.C. Part of this result may be specific to the course content: Text-based communication in the online class reinforces the skills pertinent to a literature class Another crucial factor in the difference in learning outcomes is the interaction between pedagogical biases of the online classroom and the self-selected nature of students taking an online distance education Shakespeare class through University of California Berkeley Extension Online. Those who complete the online class are often the “very models” of Malcolm Knowles’ description of an adult learner—experienced, self-directive, task-oriented, interested in problem-solving and immediate application. The differences between the online and F2F classrooms may be less crucial to learning outcomes than the degree to which the course design, regardless of technological environment, develops and supports students’ abilities to practice adult learning styles

DESCRIPTION OF THE COURSES UNDER DISCUSSION
Course Content
Chronological Structure
ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK
ONE-ALONE
One-Alone Mode Definition
Self-Pacing
PERSONAL PRESENCE IN ONE-TO-ONE AND ONE-TO-MANY MODES
ONE-TO-ONE
One-to-One Mode Definition
More Student Writing Online
More Feedback From The Teacher Online
Technological Environment Less Decisive
ONE-TO-MANY
One-to-Many Mode Definition
Dynamic Elements In Lecture Content
Students Spend More Time F2F In One-To-Many Mode
Entertainment Value Versus Reference Value
Face Time Versus Focused Time
CLASSROOM DISCUSSION
Many-to-Many Mode Definition
Active and Passive Benefits to Threaded Message Board Discussions
Composed Communication Online
Universal Participation Online
Lively But Slow?
OVERALL MIX AND IMPACT OF FOUR COMMUNICATION MODES ONLINE VERSUS F2F
OVERALL STUDENT PERFORMANCE ONLINE VERSUS F2F
Student Satisfaction and Performance Assessment
Online Environment Rewards Adult Learning Styles
Findings
SUMMARY OF CONCLUSIONS
AN ACCIDENTAL POLEMIC

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.