Diagnostic Performance of Contrast Enhanced CT Alone or in Combination with (Non-)Enhanced MRI for Colorectal Liver Metastasis

Abstract

To compare the diagnostic performance of contrast enhanced CT (CE-CT), CE-CT combined with non-enhanced MRI (NE-MRI) or contrast enhanced MRI (CE-MRI) for colorectal liver metastasis (CRLM). Sixty-six colorectal cancer patients with 198 focal liver lesions who underwent preoperative abdominal CE-CT and MRI examinations were included respectively. The images were assessed independently by two readers in three protocols (1: CE-CT, 2: CE-CT+NE-MRI, 3: CE-CT+CE-MRI). The diagnostic performance of each protocol was analyzed by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and the areas under ROC (AUCs) were calculated and compared. The detection rates of protocol 2 were 90.9%-92.9% for liver lesions and 86.4%-89.6% for CRLM, and both significantly higher than protocol 1 of 82.8%-85.4% and 76.8%-80.8% (p<0.001-0.001), whereas similar to protocol 3 of 91.9%-94.4% and 87.2%-91.2% (p 0.250-1.000). The AUCs of protocol 2 were greater than protocol 1 for all lesions (0.914-0.934 vs. 0.779-0.799, p<0.001) and lesions < 10mm (0.726-0.776 vs. 0.528-0.561, p<0.001), and were not inferior to that of protocol 3 (0.929-0.949 in all lesions and 0.754-0.821 in lesion < 10mm, p 0.053-0.162). CE-CT combined with NE-MRI offered superior diagnostic performance for CRLM compared to CE-CT alone and showed comparable performance to CE-CT combined with CE-MRI.