Development of occlusal canting identifying tool: verification, reliability and validation assessment

Abstract

IntroductionOcclusal cant (OC) is a malocclusion trait that lacks accurate clinical assessment methods. The occlusal canting identifying tool (OCIT) was invented and patented as a clinical tool to accurately identify and quantify the degree of maxillary OC. This study aimed to 1) develop a prototype of the OCIT, 2) verify the functionality of the OCIT and 3) assess the validity and reliability of the OCIT.Materials and methodsA patented OCIT design was revised, and the dimensions were finalized, followed by a three-dimensional conceptual prototype design that was reviewed and approved by the inventors. Verification was performed using a digital angle gauge to determine the accuracy of the bubble level as well as the angle between the bite plate and the protractor. For laboratory validation, 40 orthodontists measured the simulated OC at (0°, 2°, 4°, 6° and 8°) on five phantom heads using the OCIT. A reliability assessment of the tool was performed in three occasions by one orthodontist using the same laboratory settings.ResultsThe OCIT was prototyped from a medical-grade stainless steel alloy (316 L). Verification assessment revealed that the accuracy error of the bubble level (0.316° ± 0.028°) was statistically significant but clinically insignificant, while that of the angle between the bite plate and protractor (0.100° ± 0.050°) was statistically insignificant. Validation assessment showed high validity of the OCIT with no statistically significant difference between the OCIT and the reference values, having more errors in identifying smaller OC degrees compared to larger OC degrees. The intraclass correlation coefficient indicated the high reliability of the OCIT.ConclusionThe OCIT was verified and proven to be a valid and reliable clinical tool that accurately evaluates the degree of OC.