Development of measures to estimate truncation error in fault tree analysis

Abstract

Abstract The fault tree quantification uncertainty from the truncation error has been of great concern for the reliability evaluation of large fault trees in the probabilistic safety analysis (PSA) of nuclear plants. The truncation limit is used to truncate cut sets of the gates when quantifying the fault trees. This paper presents measures to estimate the probability of the truncated cut sets, that is, the amount of truncation error. The functions to calculate the measures are programmed into the new fault tree quantifier FTREX (Fault Tree Reliability Evaluation eXpert) and a Benchmark test was performed to demonstrate the efficiency of the measures. The measures presented in this study are calculated by a single quantification of the fault tree with the assigned truncation limit. As demonstrated in the Benchmark test, lower bound of truncated probability (LBTP) and approximate truncation probability (ATP) are efficient estimators of the truncated probability. The truncation limit could be determined or validated by suppressing the measures to be less than the assigned upper limit. The truncation limit should be lowered until the truncation error is less than the assigned upper limit. Thus, the measures could be used as an acceptability of the fault tree quantification results. Furthermore, the developed measures are easily implemented into the existing fault tree solvers by adding a few subroutines to the source code.