Development and validation of an audit tool for fluid management in non-critically ill adults in the emergency department.

Abstract

Especially in the emergency department (ED), it is critical to identify weaknesses in prescribing behavior of IV maintenance fluids to ensure a qualitative 24-h fluid management plan. The primary aim of this study was to develop an audit instrument to assess the pitfalls in documentation and prescribing habits of IV fluid therapy for non-critically ill patients admitted to the ED. In this study, an expert panel initially designed the tool. During different phases, adaptations were made to optimize inter-rater agreement (Fleiss' kappa, κ) and validity was determined based on the application of the tool on randomly selected electronic ED patient records. Second, the IV fluid prescription's appropriateness was addressed. The final tool consists of three parts: fluid status assessment, evaluation of maintenance fluid needs and, if present, a limited appropriateness check of the fluid prescription. A manual enhanced inter-rater agreement. κ-values achieved the target value (0.40) after three adaptation rounds, except for the category of 'clinical observations' in the assessment part (κ=0.531, 95% CI 0.528-0.534), which was acceptable. A check of the IV fluid's indication and volume was only possible with an additional expert evaluation to conclude on prescription appropriateness. Criterion related validity of the final version was high (93.4%). To conclude, the instrument is considered reliable and can be used in clinical practice to evaluate ED fluid management. Thorough documentation is essential to evaluate the appropriateness of the IV fluid prescription, to improve information transfer on IV fluid therapy to the ward and to facilitate retrospective chart review of ED prescribing behavior.