Development and use of molecular diagnostic tools to determine trophic links and interspecific interactions in aphid–parasitoid communities in Hawaii

Abstract

There has been much debate regarding the impact of parasitoid competition and hyperparasitism on the successful biological control of aphid pests. Difficulty in the evaluation of interspecific interactions and trophic links using conventional rearing and dissection methods has prevented a deeper understanding of such relationships. The analysis of trophic links in the parasitoid community associated with the melon aphid ( Aphis gossypii) in Hawaii provides a unique opportunity to assess complex interactions that occur in a system where all of the aphids and parasitoids have been introduced. Here, we developed and applied multiplex PCR assays to investigate the occurrence of in-host competition between parasitoids and/or hyperparasitoids on melon aphids collected from fields of Colocasia esculenta. To fully document the parasitoid–hyperparasitoid community within A. gossypii, both live and mummified aphids were examined. A total of 818 live and 245 mummified aphids were analyzed using the multiplex assays, with congruent rearing of over 600 mummified aphids serving as a basis for qualitative comparisons in terms of species composition and trophic linkages. The rearing and the DNA methods showed similar trends, with sharp declines in one parasitoid species followed by sharp increases in another during the course of the season. Molecular analyses revealed that hyperparasitism and multiparasitism of live aphids is remarkably low, whereas hyperparasitism of mummified aphids was extraordinarily high in both rearing and molecular analyses. In comparison to reared samples, molecular analysis of the parasitoid community was more complete and permitted the identification of previously unknown or unconfirmed trophic linkages. The potential of this approach in future studies on the biological control of aphids in Hawaii, particularly in light of new parasitoid introductions, is discussed.