Determinants of woody encroachment and cover in African savannas

Aisling P Devine,Ilya M D Maclean,Robbie A Mcdonald,Tristan Quaife

doi:10.1007/s00442-017-3807-6

Aisling P Devine, Ilya M D Maclean + Show 2 more

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-017-3807-6

Copy DOI

Abstract

Savanna ecosystems are an integral part of the African landscape and sustain the livelihoods of millions of people. Woody encroachment in savannas is a widespread phenomenon but its causes are widely debated. We review the extensive literature on woody encroachment to help improve understanding of the possible causes and to highlight where and how future scientific efforts to fully understand these causes should be focused. Rainfall is the most important determinant of maximum woody cover across Africa, but fire and herbivory interact to reduce woody cover below the maximum at many locations. We postulate that woody encroachment is most likely driven by CO2 enrichment and propose a two-system conceptual framework, whereby mechanisms of woody encroachment differ depending on whether the savanna is a wet or dry system. In dry savannas, the increased water-use efficiency in plants relaxes precipitation-driven constraints and increases woody growth. In wet savannas, the increase of carbon allocation to tree roots results in faster recovery rates after disturbance and a greater likelihood of reaching sexual maturity. Our proposed framework can be tested using a mixture of experimental and earth observational techniques. At a local level, changes in precipitation, burning regimes or herbivory could be driving woody encroachment, but are unlikely to be the explanation of this continent-wide phenomenon.

Highlights

Over the past 60 years, growing evidence suggests that savannas throughout the world are being altered by a phenomenon known as ‘woody encroachment’ (Adamoli et al 1990; Archer et al 1995; Moleele et al 2002)
Savanna ecosystems cover a high proportion of the global terrestrial land surface and have a significant role in earth–atmosphere feedback processes (Asner et al 2003; Woodward and Lomas 2004; Bond 2008)
In this review we critically examine the evidence in support of different hypotheses for woody encroachment

Summary

Introduction

Over the past 60 years, growing evidence suggests that savannas throughout the world are being altered by a phenomenon known as ‘woody encroachment’ (Adamoli et al 1990; Archer et al 1995; Moleele et al 2002). This changing balance in the proportion of trees and shrubs relative to grasses and herbs has been classed as a form of land-use degradation (Oldeland et al 2010) and has been described as one of the dominant ecological changes in the last two centuries (Polley et al 1997). We aim to provide a coherent picture of woody encroachment, to propose a suite of hypotheses that could be used to guide future research, and propose how future scientific efforts should be focused to test these hypotheses

Climatic interactions

Soil type and nutrient availability

Carbon dioxide enrichment

Fire regimes