Determinants of the Y Descent and its Usefulness as a Predictor of Ventricular Filling

Abstract

Our objective was to determine if the magnitude of the Y descent in the central venous pressure tracing could be used to determine which patients have restrictive hemodynamics. To better understand the determinants of the Y descent, we also examined the effects of changes in blood volume, changes in pleural pressure, and respiratory maneuvers on its magnitude. Studies were performed in both humans and dogs. In six anesthetized dogs, we examined the effect on the Y descent in central venous pressure (CVP) of an infusion of normal saline, a decrease in pleural pressure produced by having animals perform a Mueller maneuver, and the combination of a Mueller maneuver and volume loading. Observations were made with the chest closed, chest open, and chest and pericardium open. The state of the chest did not effect the Y descent. The Y descent was only significantly increased when a Mueller maneuver was combined with volume loading. There was a significant inverse relationship between the magnitude of the decrease in esophageal pressure and the Y descent. There was also a linear relationship between the CVP and Y descent. For the human studies, we examined patients undergoing routine cardiac surgery. They were examined during spontaneous breathing before intubation, with positive pressure breathing and closed chest, with positive pressure breathing and open chest, with an open pericardium, with a closed chest and positive pressure breathing postsurgery, and with spontaneous breathing after extubation following surgery. The Y descent was greater in spontaneous breaths postsurgery compared to before surgery, and this was associated with an increase in CVP. However, the magnitude of CVP did not correlate with the magnitude of the Y descent. A restrictive pattern in cardiac filling was identified by a lack of respiratory variation in right atrial pressure during spontaneous breaths. All patients with large Y descents had a restrictive pattern, but many patients with restrictive filling patterns did not have a large Y descent. The magnitude of the Y descent is affected by the volume status, the magnitude and direction of the changes in pleural pressure, and the compliance of the pericardial compartment. A large Y descent indicates a restrictive cardiac state, but a small Y descent does not rule out a restrictive condition because of the many interacting variables.