Detection ofOnchocerca volvulusDNA in pools of wild-caughtSimulium ochraceumby use of the polymerase chain reaction

Abstract

The presence of Onchocerca volvulus DNA in experimentally infected flies can now be detected by use of the PCR, so that, for example, one infected Simulium damnosum can be detected in a pool of 100 uninfected flies or one S. ochraceum can be detected in pools of 20-40. As this PCR technique is specific for O. volvulus, the results are not confounded by the presence of other, unimportant, Onchocerca species, and the technique could replace time-consuming, manual dissection of flies. In 1996 and 1997, pools of 16-21 Simulium ochraceum were tested by the PCR technique. These flies had been collected biting man, between 1992 and 1994, from two hyperendemic coffee estates (fincas) in Guatemala, and stored in commercial (95%) ethanol. Collections at finca Buena Vista (869 flies in 52 pools) were made 1-2 weeks and 46 weeks after 45% of eligible subjects had been treated with ivermectin for the first time. At finca El Brote, collections (360 flies in 18 pools) were made 13 weeks before and 7 weeks after 97% of eligible subjects had received their first treatment. DNA was easily recovered from simuliids that had been stored in ethanol for up to 4 years. Of the nine pools of flies with visible blood collected at Buena Vista, each of 20 flies, eight tested positive for O. volvulus DNA. In flies without blood, 13 of 22 pools collected at Buena Vista just after treatment tested positive, whereas there were 14 positives in 22 pools taken 46 weeks later (P > 0.05). At El Brote, nine of 10 pre-treatment pools were positive, compared with three of eight taken 7 weeks post-treatment (P = 0.04), indicating that the treatments in this finca had reduced infection in the vector, and possibly transmission, by about 60%. A sub-sample of Buena Vista flies was divided into 19 sets of three separate sub-pools containing heads, thoraces and abdomens. Three pools of heads alone were positive, and had corresponding pools of positive abdomens. Three positive pools of thoraces had negative corresponding pools of heads and abdomens. These results show that PCR can be used to determine the prevalence of O. volvulus DNA in wild-caught S. ochraceum. As the infection rates observed were higher than expected from dissections reported by other workers, PCR-determined rates may not be directly comparable with traditional parameters based on the dissection of flies to reveal O. volvulus larvae.