Detecting passive and active response in patients with behaviourally diagnosed unresponsive wakefulness syndrome

Abstract

The diagnosis of unresponsive wakefulness syndrome depends mostly on the motor response following verbal commands. However, there is a potential for misdiagnosis in patients who understand verbal commands (passive response) but cannot perform voluntary movements (active response). To evaluate passive and active responses in such patients, this study used an approach combining functional magnetic resonance imaging and passive listening tasks to evaluate the level of speech comprehension, with portable brain–computer interface modalities that were applied to elicit an active response to attentional modulation tasks at the bedside. We included ten patients who were clinically diagnosed as unresponsive wakefulness syndrome. Two of ten patients showed no significant activation, while limited activation in the auditory cortex was found in six patients. The remaining two patients showed significant activation in language areas, and were able to control the brain–computer interface with reliable accuracy. Using a combined passive/active approach, we identified unresponsive wakefulness syndrome patients who showed both active and passive neural responses. This suggests that some patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome diagnosed behaviourally are both wakeful and responsive, and the combined approach is useful for distinguishing a minimally conscious state from unresponsive wakefulness syndrome physiologically.