Detectability is in the eye of the beholder—the role of UV reflectance on tadpole detection and predation by a passerine bird

Abstract

The evolution of defensive coloration is dependent upon a complex combination of variables related to the prey itself, the environmental context, and predator vision/behavior. Some animals reflect ultraviolet (UV) light, which is visible to predators such as birds. Here, we report the first case of UV reflectance by a tadpole (Ololygon machadoi, Hylidae) and we investigate whether it influences tadpole detection/predation by a bird (Saltator similis, Passeriformes) on backgrounds of three different colors (two blending – yellow and dark – and one not blending – blue – to tadpole colors). We also tested whether a previous experience of the birds with the prey species would influence the search/attack effort. Although many predation attempts were recorded, birds did not consume many tadpoles. Birds attempted to/preyed upon more tadpoles on dark backgrounds in the presence rather than the absence of the UV portion of the spectrum; attempt/predation on the other backgrounds (yellow, blue) did not change between the UV conditions. The differential contrast of dark and yellow tadpole body parts against specific backgrounds may aid to disruptive properties. The interruption of tadpole body contour was probably enough to prevent detection on yellow and blue backgrounds based on low achromatic contrasts of yellow and dark body parts against such backgrounds, respectively. On dark backgrounds, however, an increase in the chromatic contrast of yellow bars caused by UV reflectance may have reached a threshold and increased tadpole detectability. Birds spent more time searching for tadpoles and visited more frequently the trays in the first than in the second trial, and several tadpoles were regurgitated after ingestion, suggesting that the existence of a potential aposematic role of the UV reflectance cannot be disregarded. Birds also spent more time inspecting blue backgrounds, which may relate to their unfamiliarity with such backgrounds. UV reflectance in O. machadoi tadpoles unveals a potential adaptative value of this feature for the larval stage, and our results indicate influence on tadpole detection by birds. The effects of such adaptation in natural habitats and its occurrence in other species deserve further studies. Defensive colorations that hamper prey detection can play an important role on prey survival, which depends on background matching ability, prey and predator behavior, and predator visual system. Tadpoles are preyed upon by a variety of visually oriented predators and background matching is likely to aid survivorship through decreased detectability. We show for the first time that tadpoles of Ololygon machadoi, although apparently benefited by camouflage, reflect UV wavelenghts, becoming more visible and maybe providing some kind of aversiveness signaling to birds. In natural conditions, however, the water column on deep stream microhabitats usually occupied by the tadpoles is expected to filter UV wavelengths and improve background matching, at least for some specific background colors.